I’m in the market for a 3100 Open. Likely a late 80’s thru 90’s. I’ve noticed a fairly wide range of horsepower in engine set ups. From 600 - 800ish. Was wondering if anyone can speak to performance difference. I’ve come across a diesel powered at 600hp but that really seems on the low side of power. I realize prop configuration will play a role. Any thoughts on this?
That being said, a diesel creates its HP at much lower RPM's and will generate a ton more torque. This allows it to spin bigger props and can negate out the larger HP difference between them and a gas engine. Look at the Ford F350's the lower HP diesel can pull a ton of weight and it takes a much larger gas engine to do the same thing. That equates to boats as well.
I will be interested to hear what others are experiencing in this boat.
I'm on my second year owning 1988 33' Open with 454 350 HP and feel it has more than enough power. Loaded down with 4 to 5 guys, fishing gear and a full tank of gas it get s on plane with some trim tab. Attached is a performance sheet from Tiara on a newer 33' Open.
10-28-2020, 03:55 PM (This post was last modified: 10-28-2020, 04:00 PM by Efreeland.)
(10-28-2020, 06:11 AM)Sans Peur Wrote: You can never have to much HP.
That being said, a diesel creates its HP at much lower RPM's and will generate a ton more torque. This allows it to spin bigger props and can negate out the larger HP difference between them and a gas engine. Look at the Ford F350's the lower HP diesel can pull a ton of weight and it takes a much larger gas engine to do the same thing. That equates to boats as well.
I will be interested to hear what others are experiencing in this boat.
I agree we never complain about too much horsepower.
(10-28-2020, 11:28 AM)Misdirection Wrote: I have an '86 3600 with twin Crusader 454's (700 hp total). I have plenty of hp and never felt under powered.
I'm up on Lake Erie, usual trip is 10 to 20 miles off shore, troll for 6 hours, run back to port. Erie is a shallow lake and gets snotty at times.
Or sometimes we make a 5 hour run down the lake to the Islands.
If I were in salt water making off shore runs, I'd probably want diesel's.
But if you plan on fishing and trolling, it can be difficult to troll a smaller boat with diesels at a slow enough speed with out trolling valves.
Sent from my SM-A505U using Tapatalk
Thank you.
I would really like diesels. The older boats with higher engine hours worry me. The boat has 600hp with the diesels. I likely won’t fish much. It is for the wife and I to explore the Chesapeake on and do some overnights.
(10-28-2020, 12:33 PM)ardoski14 Wrote: I'm on my second year owning 1988 33' Open with 454 350 HP and feel it has more than enough power. Loaded down with 4 to 5 guys, fishing gear and a full tank of gas it get s on plane with some trim tab. Attached is a performance sheet from Tiara on a newer 33' Open.
Thank you that is good information.
You have a single engine in that? All the 31’s I’ve been looking at are twin screws.
(10-28-2020, 06:11 AM)Sans Peur Wrote: You can never have to much HP.
That being said, a diesel creates its HP at much lower RPM's and will generate a ton more torque. This allows it to spin bigger props and can negate out the larger HP difference between them and a gas engine. Look at the Ford F350's the lower HP diesel can pull a ton of weight and it takes a much larger gas engine to do the same thing. That equates to boats as well.
I will be interested to hear what others are experiencing in this boat.
I agree we never complain about too much horsepower.
(10-28-2020, 11:28 AM)Misdirection Wrote: I have an '86 3600 with twin Crusader 454's (700 hp total). I have plenty of hp and never felt under powered.
I'm up on Lake Erie, usual trip is 10 to 20 miles off shore, troll for 6 hours, run back to port. Erie is a shallow lake and gets snotty at times.
Or sometimes we make a 5 hour run down the lake to the Islands.
If I were in salt water making off shore runs, I'd probably want diesel's.
But if you plan on fishing and trolling, it can be difficult to troll a smaller boat with diesels at a slow enough speed with out trolling valves.
Sent from my SM-A505U using Tapatalk
Thank you.
I would really like diesels. The older boats with higher engine hours worry me. The boat has 600hp with the diesels. I likely won’t fish much. It is for the wife and I to explore the Chesapeake on and do some overnights.
(10-28-2020, 12:33 PM)ardoski14 Wrote: I'm on my second year owning 1988 33' Open with 454 350 HP and feel it has more than enough power. Loaded down with 4 to 5 guys, fishing gear and a full tank of gas it get s on plane with some trim tab. Attached is a performance sheet from Tiara on a newer 33' Open.
Thank you that is good information.
You have a single engine in that? All the 31’s I’ve been looking at are twin screws.
I have a 1998 3100 Open with twin Crusader 454 XLi engines. They have 900 hours and it tops out at 30 knots. Cruises nicely at 18-20 knots at around 2800-3000 rpm. Full fuel and water, three guys on board. Estimate fuel at around 0.9 MPG. If you want increased range, I would go for diesels. Otherwise I think this setup is fine.